Europe is falling further behind the United States and China when it comes to key technologies.
While the two global technology powerhouses have significantly reduced their dependencies in recent years, Europe is now more reliant on foreign digital technologies than it was just over a decade ago. This is according to a comprehensive comparative study published today by the Center for Advanced Security, Strategic and Integration Studies (CASSIS) at the University of Bonn, in cooperation with the Vodafone Institute for Society and Communications.
For the study, researchers developed the so-called Digital Dependence Index (DDI), which analyzes 51 industrialized and emerging economies over a 14-year period from 2010 to 2023. The index measures dependence on a scale from 0, representing complete independence, to 1, indicating total dependence. It covers four key areas: hardware trade, IT services, software platforms, and technology patents.
According to the findings, the average digital dependence of European countries increased slightly by 0.5 percentage points between 2010 and 2023, reaching 0.69. Over the same period, China managed to reduce its score by 10.8 percentage points to 0.43. The United States improved by 6.0 percentage points and retains its global lead as the most digitally autonomous nation, with a score of 0.38.
Germany Ranks in the Middle of the Pack
Germany ranks 25th worldwide, with a DDI score of 0.73, placing it in the middle of the rankings alongside Austria and Thailand. Between 2010 and 2023, Germany’s digital vulnerability increased by 2.4 percentage points. According to the study’s authors, this is primarily due to growing dependence on software and IT services.
A closer look at the individual categories reveals a mixed picture for Germany. On the one hand, among all European countries surveyed, Germany has the lowest dependence on information and communications technology (ICT) patents. On the other hand, even this leading position within Europe falls well short by international standards. Germany still trails the United States by 26 percent, China by 20 percent, and South Korea by 12 percent.
Major Weakness in Digital Platforms
Like almost all its European partners, Germany is also almost entirely dependent on foreign providers for platforms such as operating systems, search engines, and cloud services. Together with countries such as France, Italy, and the United Kingdom, Germany belongs to a cluster of post-industrial economies that are strong in manufacturing and research but have significant gaps in their platform ecosystems.
Across Europe as a whole, the figures reveal a stark divide. The region performs relatively moderately in services, with a score of 0.42, and hardware, at 0.59. However, dependence on third countries is virtually total in platforms, with a score of 0.98, and patents, at 0.99.
The researchers also warn of a statistical distortion known as the “Ireland effect.” Ireland’s seemingly strong independence score of 0.40 is largely due to the fact that many major US corporations have established their headquarters there for tax reasons. Excluding Ireland changes the picture significantly: Europe’s trade balance in digital services for 2022 to 2024 shifts from a surplus to a substantial deficit of around USD 350 billion.
(dpa/Translation: Editorial Team)